Popular Woodworking 2005-12 № 152, страница 74

Popular Woodworking 2005-12 № 152, страница 74

METABO 15.6 VOLT

The Metabo is the largest of the three 15.6v drills tested and it weighs in at the top as well. It's hard not to compare this drill to the 14.4v drills tested, especially because Metabo had a tool in each category. The performance was good, but not as good as the other two 15.6v drills. In fact, some of the 14.4v drills were able to surpass the performance of this $300 drill.

The features on the drill are basic in all respects save one. This drill offers a "pulse" feature that

provides short, high-torque bursts of energy to make it easier to break loose stubborn screws and to start a screw or hole. It's a nice feature, but it doesn't compensate for the size and price.

Overall, we would have been ecstatic if the results from this drill would have been the results for the Metabo 14.4v. Unfortunately it falls short of providing strong competition in the small but scrappy 15.6v category.

PANASONIC 15.6 VOLT

What can I say? This higher-powered drill is lighter than eight of the 14.4v drills in the test and is smaller than some. It feels like a 12v drill but performs better than every drill except the 28v Milwaukee. It kicks tail!

That said, there's nothing particularly unusual about the drill as far as features. It has a fairly standard 55-minute charger and a two-speed transmission. The clutch works well enough, but it too suffered from finicky adjustment. The chuck is a single-sleeve locking design and the jaws in the chuck close to a perfect, tight fit.

CORDLESS DRILLS

In comparing the Panasonic to the other 15.6v drills, it performed substantially better and was significantly less expensive. This drill led us to our conclusion that buying a 15.6v drill rather than a 14.4v can be less expensive (it's the same price or less than seven of the 14.4v drills) and with much more impressive results - and in a smaller, more comfortable package!

It was an easy decision to name this drill not only the Editor's Choice in the 15.6v category, but also an overall Editor's Choice and Best Value - all in one handy package! PW

14.4-VOLT MODELS

STREET

BATTERY

AMP

BATTERY

CHARGE

TORQUE

RPM

# HOLES

# SCREWS

MOTOR

BATTERY

WEIGHT

GRIP

PRICE

PRICE

HOUR

TYPE

TIME

INCH/LB

LO/HI

MADE

DRIVEN

TEMP/°F

TEMP/°F

(LBS)

GIRTH

Bosch 33614-2G

$198.84

$54.95

2.0

NiCd

:30

500

400/1,400

20

108

136

136

5.40

6"

DeWalt DC983KA

199.99

66.25

2.4

NiCd

1:00

450

450/1,800** 25

115

140

140

5.50

55/8"

Fein ABS 14

199.99

77.00

2.0

NiCd*

:35

327

400/1,400

18

114

145

128

4.72

53/8"

Hitachi DS 14DMR

179.99

59.88

2.0

NiCd

:50

442

400/1,500

16

99

144

135

5.42

6"

Makita 6339DWDE

199.99

79.88

3.0

NiMH

1:00

450

600/1,700** 24

101

187

205

5.64

6V8"

Metabo BSZ 14.4

222.00

93.00

1.4

NiCd

:35

487

400/1,400

12

89

154

124

4.62

53/4"

Milwaukee 0612-22

161.79

54.99

1.7

NiCd

1:00

390

400/1,400

14

104

1 61

162

4.96

53/8"

Moty-Ko 14DD

199.00

59.99

2.0

NiCd

1:00

380

360/1,150

18

164

175

133

5.58

53/8"

Porter-Cable 9978

179.99

69.99

2.0

NiCd

1:00

420

450/1,400

13

76

173

146

5.60

55/8"t

Ridgid R83015

189.00

59.95

1.9

NiCd

:30

415

400/1,600

16

91

170

168

6.36

55/8"

Skil 2587-05

79.99

45.00

1.2

NiCd

1:00

250

350/1,250

9

16

133

128

4.12

53/4"

15.6-VOLT MODELS

Festool TDK 15.6 CE

400.00

110.00

2.4

NiCd

:50

220

400/1,400

29

150

158

139

5.32

5V2"

Metabo BSP 15.6 PLUS

303.00

109.00

2.4

NiCd

1:50

230

400/1,400

20

197

161

182

5.98

6V4"

Panasonic EY6432GQKW 189.90

79.99

3.5

NiMH

:55

390

450/1,450

43

287

210

151

4.82

55/8"

BASELINE MODELS

Panasonic 12 VOLT

179.00

89.99

3.5

NiMH

:55

293

400/1,300

24

57

163

130

4.24

65/8"

Milwaukee 28 VOLT

419.00

159.95

3.0

L-ION

1:00

600

600/1,800

66

300+

153

100

6.82

5V2"

*NiMH batteries also available; **Motors are three-speed, o

nly high and low are stated; fGrip is

adjustable with pads (included).

popularwoodworking.com 33